It’s 2am, you’re lying next to your partner who is sound asleep and you are up, seething about a fight you had 3 hours ago. You open ChatGPT, Claude or Gemini because it is a handy and available tool that will not judge you, and feels immediately relieving! Honestly, I get it, the anxiety you feel is not dissipating and you cannot calm your mind to sleep. Firstly, you're not doing anything wrong, in fact so many people have been utilizing AI for relationship advice and guidance. However, if you keep having the same conversation with a chatbot about the same fight with the same person, is that really going to lead to insight and help?
I'm a Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist with over 20 years in the mental health field, and lately a lot of the people calling me open with some version of "I've been talking to AI about this." Here's what I tell them.
Why so many people start with AI
It makes sense. There is a sense it is always available, always listening and always supportive. You feel a sense of trust in it, there is a real sense of authority as well.
That's real value. Don't let anyone shame you for it.
What AI is actually good for
Sorting your thoughts. Getting the swirling thoughts or worries labeled and organized can calm your nervous system enough to think.
Drafting the text or email you may or may not send. Writing the furious and initial version to the bot can feel cathartic. Rereading allows for time to process some ideas.
Learning the vocabulary. Building your working knowledge of therapy-speak such as ‘Attachment styles,’ ‘the Gottman Method,’ ‘Four Horsemen,’ and ‘stonewalling,’ this is valuable info.
Rehearsing a hard conversation. This can lead to practicing what you wish to say.
Where it runs out
It only hears your side. You're the narrator, the editor and the only witness. Your partner isn't in the chat, so the story is half-written by design.
It's built to keep you comfortable. Chatbots are sycophantic, meaning they are relentlessly agreeable. That feels great in the moment, when you wish to be seen and heard. A good therapist will tell you, respectfully, the part you don't want to hear. A good therapist will challenge you and your thoughts.
It can't read your body. When you type "I'm fine," it believes you. When I observe you, I notice if you clench your jaw, roll your eyes, and blush. That's where the real information is, and it's where somatic work starts. It is also how a real relationship with a compassionate person refines.
It can't hold two people at once. Couples therapy isn't two individual sessions happening side by side. It's me watching what happens between you, in real time, and observing and interrupting it when appropriate.
It doesn't hold you accountable. AI won't notice that you said you'd try something three weeks ago and didn't. A therapist will hold you accountable, with kindness and respect.
It isn't a licensed clinician. Therapy is only done by a professional who has extensive training, education, expertise and ongoing supervision. Therapy can only be offered by a licensed professional who has legal, ethical and professional standards. AI has no mental health training, no license, no clinical judgment about safety. If things at home feel unsafe, or you're having thoughts of hurting yourself, I encourage you to call or text 988 or call 911. Don't rely on a chatbot for your safety.
Signs it's time for a human
You've had the same fight so many times you could both do it in your sleep.
You're rehearsing conversations with AI instead of having them with your partner.
You've screenshotted a chatbot's answer to prove you're right. (I've seen it. It never works.)
Trust has been broken: an affair, a secret, a betrayal.
Your body is keeping score: bad sleep, a tight chest, dread when you hear the key in the door.
You talk to the bot more than you talk to each other.
What couples therapy does that a chatbot can't
Most stuck couples are caught in a cycle. Usually one partner is the pursuer and one is the distancer. The pursuer chases more, the distancer retreats further, and both of you end up feeling alone in the same house. Neither of you is the villain. The cycle is.
In session, we map that cycle out loud, together. I use the Gottman Method for the practical skills (how to fight, repair and rebuild trust) and Emotionally Focused Therapy for what's underneath (the fear driving the fight). And I pay attention to what your bodies are doing while you talk, because that's often where the stuck part lives.
You can't get that from a chat window. Not because AI is bad, but because the work happens between people.
Your AI chats aren't wasted
Bring them. Seriously. If you've been journaling to a chatbot, you've already done some of the hardest work: naming what hurts. Read me the parts that matter. It gives us a head start.
Common questions
Is it bad to use ChatGPT for relationship advice? No. It's useful for sorting your thoughts and learning terms. It becomes a problem when it replaces talking to your partner, or when you're using it to build a case instead of understanding the pattern.
Can AI replace couples therapy? No. AI hears one side, tends to agree with you and can't see what happens between two people in real time. Couples therapy works on the interaction itself, with a trained, licensed clinician watching it happen.
What if my partner won't come to therapy? Start on your own. Individual therapy can shift your side of the cycle, and when one person changes their moves, the dance changes too. Many partners join later.
Can we do couples therapy online? Yes. I see couples by secure video anywhere in New York, Connecticut and Florida. You can log in from the same couch or from two different places, as long as you're both in one of those states.
Ready to talk to an actual human?
I work online with adults and couples across New York, Connecticut and Florida. Couples sessions are $250 and individual sessions are $195. I'm in-network with Aetna. Learn more about couples therapy or schedule a free 15-minute call.
Juliette Doyle is a Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist with over 20 years in the mental health field, working online with adults and couples in New York, Connecticut and Florida.
← Back to blog